Trading and risk

Spread, commission and swap: what a trade really costs

Every forex or CFD trade costs money before the price even moves: you pay the spread (the gap between the buy and sell price), often a broker commission, and a swap for any position held overnight. In the example below, a trader with a USD 1,000 account making 4 trades a day of 0.5 lot pays USD 798 a month in costs, almost 80% of the account, even if the price never moves against them. Below: how to calculate each component, tables for different trading styles, swaps on long positions and what to check in a broker's terms.

Illustration for «Spread, commission and swap: what a trade really costs»

The three components of a trade's cost

CostWhat it isWhen you payWhat it depends on
SpreadThe difference between the buy price (ask) and the sell price (bid)When each trade is openedInstrument, time of day, news, account type
CommissionA fixed broker fee per trade volumeOn opening and closing (often quoted “round turn”)Account type, trading volume
SwapA charge or credit for holding a position overnightEvery night while the position is openInterest rate differential of the currencies, broker markup, trade direction

There may also be inactivity fees, deposit and withdrawal fees and account currency conversion. They do not depend on the number of trades but also reduce the result.

Spread: how to calculate it

The broker shows two prices: bid, at which you sell, and ask, at which you buy. Ask is always higher. If you buy and immediately close the trade, you lose exactly the spread.

When the spread widens

“From 0.1 pips” in an ad is the minimum during the most active hours on the most liquid pairs. The spread widens:

  • when major news is released (central bank decisions, US labour market data): liquidity disappears in those minutes;
  • at night and at the weekly open, when few participants are trading;
  • on exotic pairs and illiquid instruments, where a spread of dozens of pips is normal;
  • on holidays, when some markets are closed.

A wider spread hits stop-losses. If the spread on news grows from 1 to 6 pips, a 0.5 lot position loses another USD 25 just on the width of the price, and a tight stop-loss may trigger even though the bid chart never reached it.

Commission: raw spread accounts

Brokers offer two types of account. A standard account has no commission but a wider spread: the broker earns on it. ECN or “raw” accounts have a narrow spread but charge a commission per lot. Compare the total cost.

Read carefully how the commission is quoted: “per lot per side” means you pay twice as much for a round turn.

Swap: what it costs to hold a position

A leveraged trade is effectively a loan: you hold a position larger than your own money. For holding it overnight the broker charges a swap. On currency pairs its size depends on the interest rate differential between the two currencies and the broker's markup, so a swap can be negative (you pay) or positive (you receive), but because of the markup it is more often negative both ways.

On currency pairs the swap is usually charged triple on one night of the week, most often the night to Thursday, to cover the weekend. For CFDs on indices and stocks the triple swap often falls on Friday. The exact day and rates are in the broker's instrument specification.

For CFDs on an index or a stock, the swap is usually calculated as a benchmark rate plus the broker's markup. Buying an index CFD “for the long term” is an expensive way to invest.

Holding a USD 10,000 positionPer yearOver 5 years
Index CFD, financing 6.5% a yearUSD 650USD 3,250
Index fund with a 0.2% annual feeUSD 20USD 100

The rates are illustrative, for comparison. A 30-fold difference explains why long-term investors use the funds themselves. How they work is covered in our article on ETFs and index funds.

What a month of trading costs

Costs matter most for those who trade often and aim for small moves. The same cost per trade, USD 9.50 at 0.5 lot, for different styles:

StyleTrades a monthTrade targetMonthly costsCosts as share of target
Scalping2005 pipsUSD 1,90038%
Day trading6020 pipsUSD 5709.5%
Swing (several days)880 pipsUSD 76 + swap2.4% + swap

A scalper aiming for 5 pips gives up 38% of every winning move to costs. A swing trader pays little per trade but adds a swap for every night.

How costs change the win rate you need

Without costs, a strategy with equal take-profit and stop-loss breaks even at 50% winning trades. Costs shift that line.

Take-profit / stop-lossCost per tradeWinning trades needed to break even
10 / 10 pips050%
10 / 10 pips1.9 pips59.5%
5 / 5 pips1.9 pips69%

Hardly anyone can consistently call the direction right in 7 trades out of 10. Studies of day traders show the same picture: some participants are profitable before costs, but far fewer remain so after spreads and commissions (Barber et al., 2014). And trading rules that looked profitable on historical data often lose their edge once transaction costs are included (Bajgrowicz, Scaillet, 2012). Why indicators do not give a consistent edge is covered in “Does technical analysis work”.

Hidden costs: slippage and requotes

  • Slippage. A market order is filled at a different price from the one you saw, especially on news and with large volumes. It can be in your favour, but an honest broker fills both ways, while a dishonest one only against you.
  • Requotes. The broker refuses to fill at the current price and offers a new one. In a fast market this effectively means a worse price.
  • Pending orders on gaps. After a weekend the price may open far from Friday's close: a stop-loss is filled at the first available price, and the loss is larger than planned.

What to check in a broker's terms

  1. The instrument specification: the typical spread (the advertised minimum will not help here), lot size, pip value, swap rates for buying and selling, the day of the triple swap.
  2. Commission: per lot per side or round turn, in the account currency.
  3. Spread history: some brokers publish average spreads by hour. Check the spread at the hours when you actually trade.
  4. Other fees: inactivity, deposits, withdrawals, conversion.
  5. Regulation and protection: the licence, negative balance protection, the complaints procedure. How to check a broker in the registers is explained in “How to check a broker”.

How to reduce costs

  • Trade less. Every unnecessary trade is a guaranteed cost. The simplest way to cut costs is fewer trades.
  • Choose liquid instruments and hours. Major currency pairs during the hours when big markets are active have the narrowest spreads. We will explain why this matters in a separate article on trading sessions.
  • Avoid opening positions on news unless your strategy is built around it.
  • Compare account types by full cost: spread plus commission in pips.
  • Do not hold leveraged positions for months if the swap is negative. Long-term investments have instruments without a daily financing charge.
  • Reduce the trade size. A smaller lot reduces both the risk and the absolute costs. How to calculate position size is described in our article on risk management.

Frequently asked questions

What is a “zero spread”?

Usually a raw spread account where the spread may be close to zero during the most liquid hours, but the broker charges a commission per lot. The full cost of a trade is never zero.

Can I earn from a positive swap?

A positive swap happens when you buy a currency with a higher interest rate against one with a lower rate. But a few cents or dollars a night are easily wiped out by the exchange rate: high-yield currencies often fall sharply. Besides, the broker can change swap rates at any time.

Is there a swap on Islamic accounts?

“Swap-free” accounts do not charge a daily fee, but the broker usually compensates in another way: a fixed holding fee after several days, a wider spread or a commission. Compare the full cost.

How does a commission-free broker make money?

From spreads, swaps and, in the market maker model, from the fact that clients lose on average. Commission is not the broker's only source of income.

Are costs taken into account for tax?

Tax is calculated on investment profit, that is, taking documented expenses into account. How trading is taxed and what you need for the return is explained in our article on trading taxes.

In short

  • Every trade costs a spread, often a commission, and a swap for each night. You always pay these costs.
  • Spread = pips × pip value × lots; for 0.5 lot of EUR/USD, 1.2 pips is USD 6.
  • 4 trades a day of 0.5 lot cost USD 798 a month, almost 80% of a USD 1,000 account.
  • With costs of 1.9 pips, a 10/10 pip strategy needs 59.5% winning trades, a 5/5 one needs 69%.
  • A 3% annual swap on 1 lot of EUR/USD is USD 9 a night and USD 3,300 a year; CFDs for long-term holding cost many times more than funds.
  • Compare brokers by typical spread, round-turn commission and swaps. The advertised “from 0.0” says nothing about the real cost.

Figures in this article

  • Retail CFD accounts losing money, lower bound74%
    ESMA data, 2018
  • Retail CFD accounts losing money, upper bound89%
    ESMA data, 2018

Checked against official sources on October 30, 2026. If a figure changes, we update the article and the «Updated» date changes automatically.

Sources

  1. ESMA - ban on binary options and restrictions on CFDs for retail clients: leverage limits, 50% margin close-out, negative balance protection (27.03.2018)
  2. Bajgrowicz, Scaillet (2012). Technical trading revisited: False discoveries, persistence tests, and transaction costs. Journal of Financial Economics - the effect of transaction costs on trading rules
  3. Barber, Lee, Liu, Odean (2014). The cross-section of speculator skill: Evidence from day trading. Journal of Financial Markets, 18 - Taiwanese day traders, results before and after costs
  4. NSSMC - how to check a company's reliability using the Commission's registers (11.08.2026) (in Ukrainian)

This article is for education only and is not investment advice or a call to trade. Trading CFDs, forex and other leveraged instruments carries a high risk of losing money quickly. Spreads, commissions, swap rates and trade sizes in the examples are illustrative and show only the maths of costs: real terms depend on the broker, the instrument and the time of trading.

Spotted a mistake or an outdated figure? and we will check it against the primary source and fix it.